Intro to Saxophone Overtones Part 1 – What are They?
This article is the first in a three-part series. Once you’re done with this article, I strongly suggest you continue forwards with part part 2 and part 3.
Many sax players new to the instrument may have heard the term “overtones” thrown about without really knowing what the term means and why they should know anything about it. The fact is, knowledge of overtones as well as the practice of overtone exercises on your horn is simply a must if you’re planning on becoming a great saxophone player.
What in the World Are These Overtone Thingies?
To quote from WikiPedia:
An overtone is any frequency higher than the fundamental frequency of a sound.
In other words, if you’re playing a low Bb, there are actually other notes quietly sounding at the same time as that low Bb. And while these other pitches are sounding relatively quietly in comparison to that low Bb, they affect the sound of the saxophone massively.
To illustrate what I’m talking about, try this as a simple exercise:
- Play a middle Bb on your horn.
- Next, position your fingers to play a low Bb.
- Keeping your embouchure the same as it would be for that middle Bb, play that middle Bb BUT keep your fingers in position to play the low Bb. What you should be hearing is still that middle Bb, but with a harsher and more abrasive tone quality. This is basically the same sound you’d get if you attempted to play the low Bb but missed the note due to not enough diaphragm support.
The point of the exercise is to demonstrate that the middle Bb is the first overtone of that low Bb. Other terminology for the sound of a middle Bb played with the low Bb fingering is the “First Partial” or “First Harmonic.”
See for Yourself
Below is the entire series of overtones (aka “partials” or “harmonics”) that we can play while fingering that low Bb. Of course, towards the end of the series you get to notes that are not possible for 99.9, if not 100% of all saxophone players to play.
Again, when you play that low Bb, you’re simultaneously hearing the entire series of notes shown above, but they’re actually more felt than heard, since the majority of the sound you hear is from the fundamental, or bottom note in the series, whichever note that might be. Every single note in the playable range of the saxophone has this series of overtones above it, whether you’re playing a low Bb or a high E with the palm keys.
So in the example above, the low Bb is what’s known as the “fundamental” – as that’s the note we’re actually fingering. From there, the middle Bb is what’s known as the “first overtone” or the “first partial.” The second overtone with be the F on the top line of the staff, the high Bb would be the second overtone, and so on and so forth up the entire series as illustrated above.
So what do these overtones have to do with me?
To start with, no two sounds have the same exact balance of individual overtones.
The effect of having more pronounced upper overtones in a sax player’s sound is an overall “brightness” in tone. For example, at the extreme end of the overtone spectrum, you have the tone of Fusion/R & B saxophonist David Sanborn. Since the music he plays involves cutting through other instruments with loud overtones such as drums and electric guitar, his sound is jam-packed with upper overtones. The result is a loud and piercing sound that can penetrate the other loud sounds in a band with electric instruments.
Here is a sample of David Sanborn playing – note that this is what it sounds like when a saxophonist has a lot of upper overtones audible in their sound:
On the other extreme side of the spectrum you have the tone of jazz altoist Lee Konitz. Due to the emphasis of lower overtones in his tone, Lee’s sound is “dark” and “piping” in nature, perfect for melding into mellower sounds such as jazz piano, acoustic bass, and subtle jazz drumming. While there are no hard-and-fast rules in music, generally speaking, in a quiet acoustic jazz setting, a loud and massive laser-like tone such as that of David Sanborn would sound out of place with the rest of the instruments.
Here is a sample of Lee Konitz playing – note that this is what it sounds like when a saxophonist has a sound which emphasizes the lower overtones:
Of course, whether you go for an upper-overtone-heavy sound like players such as Sanborn, Michael Brecker, or John Coltrane, or an lower-overtone-heavy sound such as Konitz, Paul Desmond, or Zoot Sims, in the end it’s nothing more than a simple matter of taste.
The Wrap Up
Well, I’ve probably crammed enough info into your brain for one sitting, so I should stop here before you start drooling on your keyboard.
In Part 2 of the series, we’ll get into the reasons why you should practice these overtones/harmonics/partials and how they can help you improve. Cheers for now!
Sam Sadigursky
December 17, 2010 @ 2:14 pm
I’m not quite sure that a darker sound like that of Lee Konitz is due to a lack of overtones necessarily. There are a lot of other factors that go into a more cutting, Sanborn-like sound, baffle and reed strength being at the top of the list. I am sure that a lot of players with “darker” sounds have practiced overtones extensively, people like Joe Lovano, Mark Turner, Bill McHenry, and Billy Drewes. Steve Lacy was well known for his overtone practice, and he had what many people would term a dark sound.
I think overtones are great for developing any kind of sound that a player is going for, and also for developing good note placement and pitch, which is closely related to positioning your larynx properly, or what many call “voicing”. And they don’t have to be boring to work on…I always encourage students to come up with their own ways of practicing overtones to keep things interesting. This way it’s easier to make them part of your regular practice routine.
Doron
December 17, 2010 @ 2:33 pm
Heya Sam! Well, the way I see it is that the equipment can assist you in bringing out those upper partials, but the bottom line is that those upper partials are more evident in the sound of someone like David Sanborn as compared to Lee Konitz. It’s just like on an EQ, there’s a very big difference when you roll off the highs, and although the overtones are present in Konitz’s sound, he’s using his embouchure to “roll them off” a bit in order to get his cool and piping sound.
I actually read up on overtones in “The Master Speaks” by one of Allard’s students, and Joe taught that practicing overtones will allow you to play with a dark tone, but still have the upper overtones *when you need them*, so that implies that there are situations where it’s possible to not utilize the full harmonic spectrum when you’re going for a certain kind of sound.
Taking that into consideration, I would imagine that any great sax player would practice overtones quite a bit regardless of the sound they were going for, as overtones allow you to master the crucial subtleties of one’s embouchure.
We may be on the same page with this and just talking semantics, so sorry if I ramble a bit. :)
Thanks Sam!
Jeff
February 4, 2021 @ 2:42 pm
Hey im a student saxophonist with a weird issue. I play with my tongue supporting reed as well as my lip. I was wondering if this would prevent me from playing overtones, or if it will just make it a bit more difficult.
Are You a Mindful Saxophone Player? | Best. Saxophone. Website. Ever.
December 22, 2010 @ 8:04 am
[…] only on the steadiness of harmonic color in my sound. In other words, I focus on hearing the same overtones at both pianissimo and […]
Back on the Sax Part 3: Practicing Overtones | Best. Saxophone. Website. Ever.
January 30, 2011 @ 5:39 pm
[…] yes, I know, I’ve been droning on and on about overtones lately. But I’ve really been having a good time practicing the exercises from part 3 of the Intro to […]
The Value of Volume Versatility | Best. Saxophone. Website. Ever.
February 3, 2011 @ 8:10 am
[…] of a note, and it takes practice to keep that note from cracking or splitting off into an upper harmonic when playing super-loud or super-soft. Even though many of us spend the bulk of our playing time in […]
Improve Your Tone Without Picking Up the Horn | Saxaphones For Sale
February 3, 2011 @ 11:22 am
[…] your tone in a way that exercises just about every muscle necessary to form a great sound is the practicing of overtones. But there is something else we can do before we even put the entire instrument […]
The Value of Volume Versatility | Saxaphones For Sale
February 3, 2011 @ 11:22 am
[…] of a note, and it takes practice to keep that note from cracking or splitting off into an upper harmonic when playing super-loud or super-soft. Even though many of us spend the bulk of our playing time in […]
- Saxophone Embouchure Made Simple
February 9, 2011 @ 3:57 pm
[…] putting out articles that have to do with the art of saxophone tone creation, including articles on overtones, practicing on the mouthpiece, and proper positioning of the lower […]
Saxophone Embouchure Made Simple | Best. Saxophone. Website. Ever.
April 30, 2011 @ 12:37 pm
[…] putting out articles that have to do with the art of saxophone tone creation, including articles on overtones, practicing on the mouthpiece, and proper positioning of the lower […]
Revisiting the Klose Exercises | Best. Saxophone. Website. Ever.
June 25, 2011 @ 6:46 pm
[…] If you’re unfamiliar with these, go to Intro to Saxophone Overtones. […]
mrG
July 7, 2011 @ 5:59 pm
Ouch, realized later, when I went to play them, that my prior comment here had completely misread the harmonic series. F is the FIFTH, not the fourth. Hope you can delete that :)
SaxGuy214
January 29, 2012 @ 9:06 pm
What song is that in the audio clip of David Sanborn?
Doron Orenstein
January 29, 2012 @ 9:49 pm
It’s the song, Hideaway taken from the live album “Straight to the Heart.” http://www.amazon.com/Straight-Heart-David-Sanborn/dp/B000002L6N
Some people might call his music smooth-ish jazz, but regardless, Sanborn is without a doubt one of the most gifted and soulful players ever to play the sax (in my humble opinion).
SaxGuy214
January 29, 2012 @ 10:23 pm
I agree, his sound would fit into a multitude of jazz settings, including the really elaborate big band charts. This is the (not exact) kind of sound I still am striving to achieve on my alto, which I most commonly play in a big band setting.
Doron Orenstein
January 29, 2012 @ 10:32 pm
Yeah, Sanborn’s normal sound would be hard to contain in a big band setting, but he’s such a badass that I bet he could make it work, no problem.
John Caito
September 8, 2012 @ 8:55 am
Marc Russo is one of the worlds best at overtones (altissimo). His playing on the Yellowjackets “Politics” album the song “Foreign Correspondent” is smokin. He is the Doobie Brothers sax player,,listen to him play along with them on “South City Midnight Lady”. Marc is truly one of the greatest saxophonists playin today.
Doron Orenstein
September 8, 2012 @ 4:56 pm
Yeah, I remember Marc on that very Yellowjackets album. Amazing altissimo indeed. With Bob Mintzer playing in that band now, they definitely know how to pick sax players!
wayne wojnarowski
February 14, 2016 @ 10:46 am
Really loved your explanation of overtones, I’m excited to start again, I can get to the third overtone sort of OK?? when I get to D that’s when the trouble starts. Any free audio tutorials out there? I can’t remember where I read it but somebody said use the side D where is that?I just watched Dave Liebman give a clinic on overtones in France somewhere, my question is ,do you necessarily have to have $500 dollar mouthpieces, and $15,000,horns to create good tone and sound. My point being, I love the horn I’m not a pro don’t have a ton of money ,I practice every day talk to a lot of players, and quite frankly I have heard players with great gear who sound sub par, I will purchase what I need to purchase, only if I truly need it! I studied with a very talented and educated man who could hit overtones and play the you know what out of all horns. He played on a Yanigasawa 7 hard rubber mp, I think
he played on Selmer’s but I don’t think they were Mark 7’s (can’t remember),What’s your opinion? I play on a Yanigasawa alto I’m comfortable with it I think I have a decent tone I’m always trying to improve and I play on a Meyer 8 hard rubber, I’ve been hearing so much talk about GUARDALA mp’s . I would appreciate an honest opinion !
Doron Orenstein
February 15, 2016 @ 2:34 pm
Hello Wayne,
I don’t necessarily think that you need an expensive mouthpiece or sax, I think you just need to experiment and find the setup that works for you, and do a lot of practicing (obviously), since overtone exercises are anything but easy to master, so don’t get discouraged if it’s taking you longer than you thought to get proficient with these. I’d just go to a music store and try different mouthpiece and reed combinations to see if that helps a bit. Master sax teacher David Demsey recommends going for a middle-of-the-road setup whereby your reed is of a medium-ish strength, and the tip opening on your mouthpiece is pretty mid-level as well.
I hope that helps!
Doron
Robert Stock JR
February 4, 2021 @ 2:43 pm
Hey im a student saxophonist with a weird issue. I play with my tongue supporting reed as well as my lip. I was wondering if this would prevent me from playing overtones, or if it will just make it a bit more difficult.
Doron Orenstein
February 11, 2021 @ 7:36 am
Helo Robert, I can’t say I’ve heard of using the tongue to support the reed, as that would be the role of the bottom jaw. So I would definitely try and get away from the habit of holding up the mouthpiece with your tongue, as it seems as through it would make *everything* harder (especially articulation).
4 Powerful Exercises for Saxophone Sound and Flexibility » Best. Saxophone. Website. Ever.
June 23, 2024 @ 9:10 am
[…] you’re not familiar with concept of overtones (which are what this exercise is based around), keep in mind that bottom notes are the fingerings […]